You added required and type="email" to a form, and a script calls form.submit() when the user finishes. The form goes out with an empty or malformed email, and your submit listener never runs.
The cause
form.submit() is a low level method. MDN states that with it "No submit event is raised" and that "Constraint validation is not triggered." Both the validation and your submit handler are skipped by design.
The fix
Call form.requestSubmit() instead. MDN describes it as identical to activating the form's submit button: the form's content is validated, and the form is submitted only if validation succeeds. The test below uses jsdom and logs how many times the submit event fired.
const { JSDOM } = require("jsdom");
const dom = new JSDOM(`<form id="f"><input name="email" type="email" required></form>`);
const form = dom.window.document.getElementById("f");
let submits = 0;
form.addEventListener("submit", (e) => { e.preventDefault(); submits++; });
form.submit();
console.log("after submit():", submits, form.checkValidity());
form.requestSubmit();
console.log("after requestSubmit() on invalid form:", submits);
form.elements.email.value = "a@b.co";
form.requestSubmit();
console.log("after requestSubmit() on valid form:", submits);Expected output: submit() leaves the count at 0 and the form invalid, requestSubmit() on the invalid form leaves it at 0, and requestSubmit() once the email is filled in raises it to 1. jsdom prints a "Not implemented" notice for submit() because it does not navigate. That is a jsdom limitation, not a problem with the code.
Caveats
If you validate in your own code instead, call form.checkValidity() before deciding whether to send. In the test above it returns false while the required email is empty.
Back to All Questions